Markets & Rates

100,000 Tractors Gone, Rates Up 25%, Why Carriers Still Fail

The U.S. fleet shed 100,000 for-hire tractors in a year, pushing active count to its lowest since early 2022. Contract rates jumped 25% year over year, but the lag between rising rates and battered balance sheets is forcing layoffs and bankruptcies.

100,000 Tractors Gone, Rates Up 25% — Why Carriers Still Fail
Photo: PTL Petroleum · CC BY-SA 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

Why are carriers going bankrupt when rates are rising?

The U.S. trucking market lost roughly 100,000 for-hire tractors over the past year, including about 51,000 in a single month this summer. The active tractor count now sits at its lowest level since early 2022. Contract rates are up 25% year over year, hitting $2.88 per mile linehaul as of November 13. Spot rates climbed to $360 all-in, up 2.86% month over month. Yet carriers are still folding. The reason: rates are rising, but not fast enough to rescue operators whose finances were crushed during the prolonged period when rates ran well below costs.

The capacity exodus is not evenly distributed. Fleets running 20 to 1,000 trucks are actually up 12% over the last five years. But the edges of the industry are contracting sharply. Carriers with 1 to 6 trucks have erased their entire pandemic-era expansion. Fleets with more than 1,000 trucks are down about 9% as larger carriers deliberately park equipment to maximize utilization rather than grow headcount.

Diesel topping $6 a gallon adds further pressure for any operator not fully offsetting fuel costs through surcharges. Increased regulation and liability concerns are compounding the squeeze on small fleets. Large carriers face a persistent driver recruiting and retention challenge.

What the rate recovery looks like on the ground

Truckload contract rates (VCRPM1 linehaul) hit $2.88 as of November 13, a 25% jump year over year. Intermodal contract rates reached $1.78, up more than 6.5% year over year, still representing substantial savings versus truck for shippers willing to convert freight. The all-in spot rate (NTI USA) stood at $360, up 2.86% month over month.

Overall tender rejection rates are holding just below 13% at 12.87%, down roughly 1% month over month but supported by the tightening tractor supply. Flatbed and refrigerated tender rejections are both hovering around 20% to 21%, levels that have held since late September. Dry van rejections are softer at 10.4%.

Volumes, measured by the STVI index, rose about 4% from October 1 (11,068) to the current reading of 11,405, even as the index slipped 3% to 4% week over week. Early signs of pre-peak tightening are showing out of California, with rising volumes in parts of Texas and the western Midwest, including Kansas.

The lag that kills small fleets

Rates are improving, but the lag effect is the killer. A carrier that ran at a loss or near breakeven for 18 months does not recover the day contract rates reset 25% higher. The balance sheet damage is already done. Cash reserves are gone. Equipment notes are overdue. Insurance renewals come due at 30% higher premiums than a year ago. The rate recovery has to be sustained long enough to rebuild working capital, and many small fleets do not have the runway.

The 51,000-tractor drop in a single month this summer was not a voluntary exit. That was forced liquidation, carriers parking trucks they could not afford to fuel or insure, owner-operators handing back keys to lenders. The fact that fleets with 1 to 6 trucks have erased their entire pandemic-era expansion tells you who absorbed the worst of the downturn.

What shippers and carriers should plan for

Shippers should budget for higher contract rates into 2027. The tightening tractor supply and rising rejection rates signal that the easy capacity is gone. Pursue mode conversion to intermodal where feasible, given the 6.5% year-over-year climb in intermodal contract rates still leaves substantial savings versus truck. Monitor reefer and Midwest demand trends, where rejection rates are holding at 20% to 21%.

For carriers, the advice is pointed: really understand your true costs when pricing out that freight. The lag between rate recovery and financial recovery means you cannot afford to underprice loads today hoping volume will carry you through. Diesel at $6 a gallon, insurance up 30%, and the regulatory burden climbing means your cost floor is higher than it was two years ago. Price accordingly or join the 100,000 tractors that left the market.

The contract rate reset is running at the strongest pace in years, with shippers paying 9% more on second-tender loads and 20% on third-plus. That pricing power is real, but it only helps carriers who are still solvent when the checks clear.

More from Tess Crawford